Etsy buyer feedback

Words from our collectors.

Your feedback matters to us. We want every order to feel personal, arrive with care, and become a favorite part of the season. These are the notes left by Etsy buyers along the way.

Visit Etsy
4.89Average Etsy rating
204Etsy reviews
2023–2026Buyer feedback

Etsy reviews

Reviews rated three stars and above, most recent first. Reviews from our Etsy shop as of October 26, 2026.

2026

  1. Etsy customer

    “Nice pumpkin lantern! Love the colors and image. Only issue is with the bottom cap closure is a little loose otherwise, very nice.”
  2. Etsy customer

    “Emballage soigné et article arrivé en parfait état.”
  3. Etsy customer

    “Absolutely wonderful experience with this seller. The lamp is gorgeous and as described. I will be buying from this seller again! The item was packed well and arrived on time.”
  4. Etsy customer

    “Absolutely wonderful experience with this seller. The lamp is gorgeous and as described. I will be buying from this seller again! The item was packed well and arrived on time.”
  5. Etsy customer

    “Very cool item and it will be a nice addition to my collection”
  6. Etsy customer

    “The Poe and Raven lantern is just adorable. The perfect gift for the Poe/Halloween decor lover. Great quality, price and quick shipping. Thanks so much!”
  7. Etsy customer

    “Product is exactly as shown. Received promptly! Would buy from seller again!”
  8. Etsy customer

    “This is the second I have ordered from this seller, I'm sure I'll want the rest.”
  9. Etsy customer

    “Gorgeous wee night light.smaller than I thought but very well made.its beautiful.i posted pics of it up on my Edgar Allen Poe group page and everyone loves it.”
  10. Etsy customer

    “This is pretty small but I still really liked it.”

2025

  1. Etsy customer

    “Not only was this piece exactly as described, but the packaging it came in was amazing!”
  2. Etsy customer

    “Really original and one of a kind gift from a very prompt and depensdable seller.”
  3. Etsy customer

    “My mother in law is going to love this. Cannot wait to gift it to her.”
  4. Etsy customer

    “A little smaller than I thought, but all in all I am happy.”
  5. Etsy customer

    “Loved the ornament and was pleasantly surprised by the nice thank you gift that was included with my purchase.”
  6. Etsy customer

    “This is so cute and I want more!”
  7. Etsy customer

    “This is a great gift! The lantern lights up brightly. It looks very nice. I like that it has two decorative sides. My Son is going to like this.”
  8. Etsy customer

    “Nice lantern, looks great with LED on”
  9. Etsy customer

    “Perfect ornament to add to the tree this year! Quickly shipped, carefully packaged.”
  10. Etsy customer

    “The cutest Lil' Krampus ever!”
  11. Etsy customer

    “More beautiful than I expected! Fantastic quality”
  12. Etsy customer

    “Is a lil Krampus like pictured”
  13. Etsy customer

    “My friend loved this! It was a fun Halloween gift for her.”
  14. Etsy customer

    “My second time buying from this shop. Took no time getting here. I know I'll be ordering from this again.”
  15. Etsy customer

    “Beautiful lamp, nice gift for any fan”
  16. Etsy customer

    “Really great lantern, perfect for a vintage Halloween!”
  17. Etsy customer

    “Great gift item for those who like Halloween”
  18. Etsy customer

    “The gold paint is applied a little sloppy.”
  19. Etsy customer

    “Cute little lantern. Thank you”
  20. Etsy customer

    “Cute, just like photo, very satisfied.”
  21. Etsy customer

    “This lantern is awesome. The image is clear and the lantern is exactly as described. Will be ordering more.”
  22. Etsy customer

    “Love the lantern, received it quickly and really appreciated the free gift that came with my order. Will definitely order again from this shop.”
  23. Etsy customer

    “I like the way the lantern looks in my display. It was all plastic, more than I thought it would be, but still feels like a nice quality product. Looks great lit up.”
  24. Etsy customer

    “I really like it it!”
  25. Etsy customer

    “This was a gift for a dear person in my life. I have not seen it yet tho he said it is so cool. Spooky and classy Halloween piece of art. The seller was super sweet as well. Sent a cute Edgar Allan Poe item as a special gift. Which was perfect as he loves EAP. Couldn't find a sweeter seller and such classy Halloween themed art!! THANK YOU!”
    Sleepy Hollow LED Lantern: Headless Horseman & Ichabod CraneReviewed item · Product listing photoSleepy Hollow LED Lantern: Headless Horseman & Ichabod CraneView item on Etsy ↗
  26. Etsy customer

    “The headless horseman will look great on my Halloween tier tray!”
  27. Etsy customer

    “Everytime this shop gets everything done so perfect. They're so kind. Our jar was dropped and broke when we reached out to see if we could get a new jar because we loved our so much. Our lid was fine so they helped us out by making it so we could just get a jar. that's is some serious customer service.”
  28. Etsy customer

    “Amazing little light!!! It's adorable”
  29. Etsy customer

    “It's a nice item. I mistakenly thought it would flicker like a candle but it does not.”
  30. Etsy customer

    “Cool little Halloween lantern that looks great with my other small decor—thanks!”
  31. Etsy customer

    “This was a great gift for a fellow friend d who also loves Halloween”
  32. Etsy customer

    “Beautiful lantern. Will look great with my other headless horseman decor. A+”
  33. Etsy customer

    “It will be fun to have on the table for our Sleepy Hollow dinner party.”
  34. Etsy customer

    “I didn't realize this was a 2-sided ornament. The light inside illuminates the scene beautifully. Perfect!”
  35. Etsy customer

    “Wonderful! Perfect addition to my halloween display”
  36. Etsy customer

    “Love it. Great gift. May have to order one for myself.”
  37. Etsy customer

    “Second one we've bought we love it so much”
  38. Etsy customer

    “I just love my new Krampus so much!!! He's perfect! I can't wait for Yule now so I can put him out with his buddies in my massive Krampus collection.”
  39. Etsy customer

    “The item matched the description, great quality. Look even better in person.”
  40. Etsy customer

    “It is very well crafted, it is well lit, and very whimsically.”
  41. Etsy customer

    “Very cute! They are plastic and small, but a very unique decoration.”
  42. Etsy customer

    “OMG, so stinking cute! All the people on my departmental work have labubu dolls, can't wait to put out my sweet but naughty looking krampus!”
  43. Etsy customer

    “Better than expected! Great seller and can't wait to gift this to my husband for Father's Day!”
  44. Etsy customer

    “I purchased this for my underground bookshop and it fits right in!!”
  45. Etsy customer

    “Looks great on my bookcase”
  46. Etsy customer

    “very nicely designed. appreciated the extra photo magnet. safely packaged and shipped quickly. I bought both nosferatu's for my train layout. I will add a photo in the future.”
  47. Etsy customer

    “very nicely designed. appreciated the extra photo magnet. safely packaged and shipped quickly.”
  48. Etsy customer

    “Item was just as described.”
  49. Etsy customer

    “As described, very pleased with the ornament”
  50. Etsy customer

    “Seller addressed my needs right away shipped my order quickly and packaged well. Love it, thank you.”
  51. Etsy customer

    “I love it. It matched the description perfectly. Thx for a great product !”
  52. Etsy customer

    “Excellent quality that was better than the picture. Fast shipping, love it”
  53. Etsy customer

    “Arrived quickly and is as pictured, very pretty! Was well packaged to prevent any damage.”

2024

  1. Etsy customer

    “better than expected - perfect gift for krampus fan ;-)”
  2. Etsy customer

    “I sent this as a gift and it is lovely. We did hit a bump during shipping, but they took care of it very efficiently. Even with that the shipping time was quick. I would definitely purchase from this store again.”
  3. Etsy customer

    “Great ornament and fast shipping!!”
  4. Etsy customer

    “Very pretty lantern. I was happy to find one on Etsy as by the time I took my annual Christmas trip to Galena, I could not find any there to purchase in the stores in Galena.”
  5. Etsy customer

    “It’s perfect! Thank you so much!!”
  6. Etsy customer

    “Nice ornament and it arrived safely!”
  7. Etsy customer

    “It’s a great ornament! My husband is delighted with how it turned out!”
  8. Etsy customer

    “I got one for me and for my sister. Perfect for Krampus enthusiasts! Exceeded expectations, looks great on our tree!”
  9. Etsy customer

    “It’s perfect just as described”
  10. Etsy customer

    “Gorgeous ornament. I just love it! The problem is does he stay on the black tree or with the Krampus collection...?!”
  11. Etsy customer

    “Very quick shipping and excellent quality!”
  12. Etsy customer

    “Thank You. Arrived very quickly.”
  13. Etsy customer

    “Made a great gift for a German themed Christmas. Item was high quality! Thank you!”
  14. Etsy customer

    “This is a really nice ornament! I was so excited when I received it! It shipped very fast as well!”
  15. Etsy customer

    “Exactly as described and pictured”
  16. Etsy customer

    “My mom will love this gift, we go on an annual mother/daughter trip to Galena this will make a perfect stocking stuffer for Christmas! I appreciate the magnet included, I kept that for myself :)”
  17. Etsy customer

    “Arrived quickly and made very well!”
  18. Etsy customer

    “A great quality ornament! Would also make a great gift!”
  19. Etsy customer

    “Love it. Received in time for Krampusnacht!”
  20. Etsy customer

    “This is a great item! Fast shipping and packaged nicely. The free Galena magnet was a nice surprise.”
  21. Etsy customer

    Left a 5-star Etsy rating.

  22. Etsy customer

    “Perfect gift for anyone who appreciates the charm of Galena!”
  23. Etsy customer

    “Jars are awesome awesome awesome”
  24. Etsy customer

    “Jars are awesome keeps my weed fresh.”
  25. Etsy customer

    “Stash jars are awesome. I had to buy two more for gifts.😃”
  26. Etsy customer

    Left a 5-star Etsy rating.

  27. Etsy customer

    “Thank you so much! It has all of my indica and sits next to the Volcano.”
  28. Etsy customer

    “This item so so incredibly amazing and perfect. They even give you a toothpick so make your life easier pushing the on button!!!!”
  29. Etsy customer

    “Beautifully packaged and well made. Thank you!”
  30. Etsy customer

    “Great item creepy but cool”
  31. Etsy customer

    “I am excited about this item, it is a gift that I think will be appreciated”
  32. Etsy customer

    “Great product for my family's ornament exchange! Shipped very quickly and arrived well-packaged.”
  33. Etsy customer

    “We moved to Galena and I wanted an ornament that was locally made and it is beautiful! Love it!!”
  34. Etsy customer

    “Wonderful was a home run gift”

2023

  1. Etsy customer

    “Ornaments very nice! Great customer service!”
  2. Etsy customer

    Left a 5-star Etsy rating.

  3. Etsy customer

    “A beautiful piece that captures the magic of the Night of the Luminaria in my hometown. Thank you!”

Even Santa Gets a Little Coal

We believe in transparency, even when the feedback isn’t all twinkly lights. These are our one- and two-star reviews, shared in full. Every experience matters, and we always welcome honest feedback to help us do better.

  1. Etsy customer

    “Sorry but wouldn't buy again.”
  2. Etsy customer

    “This looks like something you’d find in the dollar store and we’re so disappointed. It’s not nearly as cute as it appears in the photo. I don’t even think we can put it in our shop so in the garbage it goes.”